Does Canadian data belong to Canadians? What U.S. tech dependency puts at risk

Nextcloud - Nextcloud Hub 26 Summer:
Nextcloud Hub 26 Summer:
Autonomy for Teams, Office on desktop, a fresh take on Photos

Explore what’s new in the release blog!

Read more

In Canada, the digital sovereignty debate has focused largely on infrastructure and data location, while giving less attention to who owns and controls the software. Data-sovereignty researcher Joshua van Es found that 91% of communications tools available to Canadian organizations, including email, video calls and messaging, fall under foreign jurisdiction. Amazon, Microsoft and Google hold 85% of Canada’s public cloud market, which is well above their 66% global average, according to the report from the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project.

In this article, we explore what this dependency puts at risk and what Canadian organizations can learn from Europe’s digital sovereignty movement as they seek alternatives to U.S. technology and closer ties with the EU.

How digitally sovereign is Canada?

In our Digital Sovereignty Index, Canada scores 14.79 points, which puts it below the average score in the EU. That’s slightly higher than the U.S. (13.49), but well behind top performers such as Finland (64.30) and Germany (53.70).

What do Canadians think about this dependency? 86% of public servants in Canada fear that the public could lose trust in government if personal citizen information is stored outside Canada, according to a KPMG Canada report. This matches the sentiment among Canadian consumers. According to CIRA Canadian Internet Trends 2026, 67% of Canadians say it’s important for personal data to be stored in Canada, while only 8% say it’s unimportant.

Seven of the eight cloud providers approved for use by the Canadian federal government are American.

Data from Tech Policy Press

Cloud and collaboration are the most exposed layers

Canada, like many countries worldwide, remains heavily reliant on U.S. Big Tech for collaboration tools, including cloud storage, office software, chat and videoconferencing:

Why is this a big problem?

Canada does not have a federal equivalent to the EU GDPR. Instead, it has a combination of federal and provincial privacy legislation. For example, a GDPR-style law already exists in Quebec: Law 25. PIPEDA, the federal private-sector privacy law, governs the collection, use and disclosure of personal information in the course of commercial activities.

Organizations using cloud services have three important responsibilities under PIPEDA:

Bill C-36, tabled on June 15, 2026 and still awaiting second reading, would replace PIPEDA with the Protecting Privacy and Consumer Data Act, require a privacy impact assessment before personal data leaves Canada, and allow fines of up to C$10 million or 3% of global revenue.

Data residency is not data sovereignty

The Government of Canada defines data sovereignty as Canada’s right to control access to and disclosure of its digital information, subject only to Canadian laws. As cyber defence policy analyst Dr. Alexander Rudolph puts it, «Microsoft will listen to the U.S. government» regardless of another country’s domestic laws.

Sensing Europe’s push for independence, Big Tech companies have responded with a new strategy: marketing services as “sovereign” because the data is stored in local data centres and/or the services are managed by local staff, while the provider remains subject to foreign laws.

In short, sovereignty-washing. Emily Osborne, a policy researcher at the Canadian Shield Institute, compares this term to the “maple-washing” Canadians saw when U.S. tariffs began.

It is easy to market a service as sovereign by emphasizing local data hosting and making misleading claims about the resilience it provides. The data is stored within national borders and subject to local laws, so doesn’t that make it sovereign?

The tale of resilience

As we put it in our analysis of Microsoft’s “Digital Principles for Europe“, if resilience depends on legal promises from a U.S.-based vendor, it’s not resilience, but risk management. Microsoft as a company is subject to U.S. law, and that includes the CLOUD Act.

Under the U.S. CLOUD Act, U.S. authorities can require U.S.-based companies to disclose data within their control, even when that data is stored outside the United States.This means that storing data in Canada does not, by itself, protect it from U.S. legal demands. And while a Canadian entity owned and managed in Canada generally falls outside of the CLOUD Act, a Canadian subsidiary of a U.S. company can be compelled to comply with it.

A promise to challenge government orders doesn’t change that. Microsoft’s own transparency report shows it received 190 law enforcement requests worldwide for enterprise cloud customer data in the second half of 2025. Nearly half of it resulted in some form of handover, where 45 of 94 cases included customer content.

In 2025, Anton Carniaux, Microsoft France’s director of public and legal affairs, told the French Senate he could not guarantee French public sector data would never reach U.S. authorities without French consent.

Legally, the situation would not be different for any company in Canada that relies on U.S. providers.

Learnings from Europe

So what can a Canadian organization seeking to regain control over its IT learn from the European digital sovereignty practice?

European governments and business have been looking for a way out of lock-in with U.S. Big Tech in the past decade, especially since Trump’s second term began in 2025. Many countries are already taking digital sovereignty very seriously.

In France, digital sovereignty grows at national scale. France’s Ministry of National Education is rolling out Nextcloud to 1.2 million employees. The Île-de-France region uses it for 550,000 teachers and students.

Austria is migrating away from Microsoft, avoiding disruption with a unique hybrid model. A federal ministry moved 1,200 employees from Microsoft to Nextcloud in a few months, while keeping familiar workflows.

In the German state of Schleswig-Holstein, open source is a state strategy. The state is among the first to start shifting its administration to digitally sovereign technology. Another German state, Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, is already building on its publicly available strategy, introducing a sovereign collaboration platform for state and municipal public servants with a goal of reaching more than 50,000 employees.

In Switzerland, open source is written into law. In the Netherlands, Nextcloud saw an eight-fold increase in inquiries about sovereign workplace tools in 2025.

The list goes on. Europe’s move toward digital sovereignty is still young, especially compared to its decades of reliance on U.S. Big Tech, and calling the region fully digitally resilient would be an overstatement. But a growing number of public and private sector organizations show how to turn digital independence from theory into practice.

That experience gives Canadian organizations a head start: the path has already been tested.

Good fences make good neighbors. It’s time to take control over your data

Who really controls your data when a foreign government has legal access to your cloud? Who owns the technology roadmap, licensing, updates, product availability and terms of service? As we wrote in our recent article on Microsoft’s so-called “Sovereign Cloud“, while customers may control more settings – they certainly won’t get any control over the platform itself.

Nextcloud is a good place to begin establishing control over your IT. It is a 100% open source collaboration platform that runs in a private cloud, self-hosted or through a trusted local provider who knows your regulations. In Canada, Nextcloud partners with cloud service provider cloud&more that is helping businesses, organizations, and enterprises to retain data control and uphold privacy.

With a paced migration plan, you avoid disrupting your work while your users adopt new tools without pushback. Learning from thousands of organizations in Europe, our experts at Nextcloud can help you map out your scenario. Feel free to look at Nextcloud migration cases and connect with our engineering team to request an assessment.

For larger organizations that need to run and enterprise-scale setup, we recommend the Nextcloud Enterprise package. It comes with direct support from the Nextcloud engineering team and gives you the opportunity to contribute to future roadmap.

Join us in Ottawa

Enterprise Day Ottawa

Our upcoming event is designed for IT professionals, project managers, decision-makers, and public sector leaders, exploring how to regain control over digital infrastructure and build secure, sustainable, and digitally sovereign environments. Date and venue to be announced soon. Pre-register now: